Pay your Church Mutual Insurance premium online with ePAY, by phone, or by mail, and set up recurring payments from your bank account or card.
Sign in or register for Church Mutual Customer Account Access
View Church Mutual payment options
Online Bill Pay with ePAY
Church Mutual’s Customer Account Access / ePAY portal lets you view and pay bills online.
- Log in or create an account with your Church Mutual account number, ZIP code, and a valid email address.
- Once signed in you can view billing statements, see online payment history, make one‑time payments, or set up recurring automatic payments from your computer or mobile device.
Pay by Phone
You can pay your Church Mutual bill over the phone using their automated system.
Have your account number and payment method ready when you call.
Pay by Mail
You can mail check payments to Church Mutual.
- Mailing address for payments:
Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.
PO Box 2912
Milwaukee, WI 53201‑2912
Include your account or policy number on the check and mail early enough for on‑time delivery.
AutoPay & Agent‑Billed Policies
- In ePAY, you can set up recurring payments so your premium is drafted automatically each billing cycle.
- If your policy is billed by your agent instead of Church Mutual, send payments directly to your agent, as indicated on your invoice.
Church Mutual Bill Pay FAQs
How do I make a Church Mutual payment online?
Register or log in to Customer Account Access, then use ePAY to make a one‑time payment or set up recurring payments from your bank account or card.
What phone number do I use to pay my Church Mutual bill?
Call 800‑554‑2642, choose option 3, then option 1, and follow the prompts to pay by phone.
